Erythritol vs. Monk Fruit: Which is Better? A Natural Sugar Substitute Debate

erythritol-vs-monk-fruit.jpg

Before I share a helpful article of on the subject, I want to let you know where I stand. I have been using Monkfruit for a while to sweeten my “Fatty Morning Matcha” and I just recently tried Xylitol after a friend suggested it. While doing some research on the two sugar subs, I found that Xylitol has an inconsistent review from experts.

While all agree that Xylitol is the most similar to the real deal, it is up for debate on whether it creates a blood glucose and insulin response, although reduced. It has also come to my attention that Xylitol has carbohydrates in the form of “fillers”. This may not be a big deal to those who don’t care about keeping their bodies in ketosis and just trying to cut back on sugar, but for those who intermittent fast like me, this is an issue.

Monk Fruit on the other hand is 100% natural with no fillers and ALL experts agree that it does not raise your glycemic index. If you can get over the fact that Monk Fruit does not taste like real sugar, I believe that it’s the best option.

I have posted a great breakdown of sugar substitutes below by the The Diet Doctor.

To my fasters out there-keep in mind that while you are in the “Boot Zone”, that 8 hour eating period, you can and should take advantage of using natural sugar such as honey or dates, as a sweetener!

Ratings

The numbers corresponding to each sweetener represents the estimated long-term impact each product may have on blood sugar and insulin levels as compared to the same amount of sweetness from white sugar.

For the purposes of this scale, pure white sugar is defined as having a number of 100.

The question marks by those products with “zero” represent what is currently known about their impact on blood glucose and insulin response only. These products are relatively new and their full effect on obesity, diabetes, liver health, gut microbiome and long term risk for metabolic or cardiovascular disease is not yet known. More research is needed.

The products that have numbers with asterisks reflect the fact that these products contain some carbs, in some cases as fillers (typically dextrose). For example, a packet of Splenda provides about the same sweetness as two teaspoons of sugar, which equals 8 grams of sugar. The packet contains about 0.9 grams of carbohydrate as glucose (dextrose). That’s 0.9 / 8 = 0.11 times the effect of sugar, for an equal amount of sweetness. Pure 100% dextrose has a number of 100, so Splenda gets a number of 100 x 0.11 = 11.

The asterisks by xylitol and maltitol reflect that these products do create a blood glucose and insulin response, although reduced. The number compares that relative response, out of 100, to the equivalent sweetness of pure dextrose.

If you are trying to stay in ketosis, avoid the sweeteners in the middle and red zone. Primarily use stevia or erythritol if you need sweeteners – though their long-term health impacts are not yet fully known.

Beware: the sweetener snare

The sweeteners to the left above might only have small or even negligible direct effects on weight and blood-sugar levels. But that’s not the only concern.

Here’s the potential sweetener trap: eating sweet-tasting foods and drinks may promote the craving for more sweet-tasting treats. Cravings aren’t kicked to the curb, they’re coddled and kept.

Even the no-calorie sweeteners, like stevia and erythritol, are typically added to foods that mimic or replace the foods that the keto diet eliminates — sugary soft drinks, cakes, cookies, muffins, pastries, ice creams, candies, dessert bars, energy bars, and more. They tend to promote snacking and extra consumption of desserts and treats, typically eaten when not hungry, dramatically raising the risk that you may eat more than you need.

They also keep you tied to old patterns of your former high-carb eating, such as giving yourself sweet rewards that often contributed to weight gain and metabolic issues in the first place. They may slow or stall weight loss or even cause weight gain on the keto diet.

They may also trigger a relapse to non-keto eating.

Even the zero calorie sweeteners in diet soft drinks may possibly contribute to long-term weight gain and metabolic issues.

All sweet tastes, whether real sugar or sugar substitutes, act upon the same sweet taste receptors of the tongue and trigger similar brain neural reward pathways that according to researchers, “perpetuate their intake,” so they can maintain sugar addictions and cravings.

Moreover, zero-calorie sweeteners’ impacts on pregnant women, the developing fetus and young children are unknown and could be potentially risky for long term metabolic health.

More research is certainly needed.

All of these reasons are why we at Diet Doctor encourage people on a keto diet to ideally avoid all sweeteners, if possible.

We do understand, however, that many people feel they need a sweet treat every so often. For some, facing a future devoid of birthday cake and ice cream could remove some joy from their lives. An occasional sweet treat – especially one made with stevia, erythritol or monk fruit — might sometimes make sustaining the keto diet much easier.

Fortunately, over time, the keto diet reduces cravings for sweet-tasting foods for most people. It gets easier to control or ignore cravings; the desire for sweets diminishes.

Many then find that the natural sweet taste of wholesome foods emerge. Tastebuds can become more attuned to subtle and rewarding flavours. The desire and need for sweeteners ease.

Until that time when sweeteners’ siren call no longer lures you, if you do want to indulge occasionally, here is what you need to know to make the best choices.


LC-Sugar-2.jpg

Using sugar as a sweetener

Real sugar as a sweetener comes in many shapes and forms: white, brown, demerara, icing, confectionary, maple syrup, coconut sugar, date sugar, and more.

Real sugar is a double molecule of glucose (50%) and fructose (50%). That makes sugar 100% carbs, and all these sugars have identical (bad) impacts on weight gain, blood glucose, and insulin response.

On a keto diet, sugar in all its forms is strictly avoided. It will derail your progress. Treat it like poison.

Note that many sweeteners – white or brown sugar, maple syrup, coconut sugar and dates – have a number of exactly 100. This is because these sweeteners are made up of sugar. To get the same amount of sweetness as white sugar, you’ll get pretty much an identical effect of these sweeteners on blood sugar, weight and insulin resistance.

Sugar is bad, no surprise, so these are bad options, especially if you’re on a keto diet. Avoid.

Worse than sugar: pure fructose

What’s even worse than sugar? Fructose. That’s because it goes straight to the liver and may promote fatty liver, insulin resistance, central obesity, and unhealthy lipid profiles, especially when consumed in excessive amounts.

Unlike pure sugar with its pairing of glucose and fructose, sources of fructose are much slower to raise blood sugar and are given a lower glycemic index (GI) rating.

LC-Fructose.jpg

But don’t let that low GI rating fool you! Fructose may still do a lot of metabolic harm over the long term — even more than pure sugar.

Fructose sweeteners — high fructose corn syrup, fruit juice concentrate, honey, molasses, agave syrup — are labeled 100+ in our image because of their detrimental long-term impact. They could be called super sugars. Agave syrup is the worst of all, with the highest fructose content: more than 60%.

Don’t eat any fructose sweeteners on the keto diet.

 

Zero-calorie sweeteners

While all sweeteners have potential for negative impacts, if sustaining your keto journey is helped by the consumption of sweets from time to time, here are the 3 choices that may do the least harm.

  1. Stevia

  2. Erythritol

  3. Monkfruit


Option #1: Stevia

Stevia is derived from the leaves of the South American plant Stevia rebaudiana, which is part of the sunflower family. Indigenous peoples in Paraguay and Brazil used the intensely sweet leaves in teas, medicines and to chew as a treat, most often simply taking fresh leaves or drying the leaves for various uses.

Commercial use and marketing of the natural leaves is not permitted in the US. These days the active sweet compounds, called stevia glycosides, are extracted and refined in a multi-step industrial process to meet with US and European regulatory requirements. The FDA, while not approving the unrefined leaves, has designated the refined extract as “Generally Regarded as Safe (GRAS).”

Pros

  • It has no calories and no carbs.

  • It does not raise blood sugar or insulin levels.

  • It appears to be safe with a low potential for toxicity.

  • Stevia is very sweet — 200 to 350 times the sweetness of sugar — and a little goes a long way.

Cons

  • While intensely sweet, it doesn’t taste like sugar.

  • Many people find stevia has a bitter after taste.

  • It is challenging to cook with to get similar results as sugar and cannot be simply swapped into existing recipes.

  • There’s not enough long term data on stevia to discern its true impact on health of frequent users.

Sweetness: 200-350 times sweeter than table sugar.

Products: Stevia can be purchased as a liquid, powdered or granulated. Note that granulated stevia, such as the product Stevia in the Raw, contains the sugar dextrose. Some granulated stevia products, like Truvia, also contain erythritol and fillers.


Option #2: Erythritol

Made from fermented corn or cornstarch, erythritol is a sugar alcohol that occurs naturally in small quantities in fruits and fungi like grapes, melons and mushrooms. It is only partially absorbed and digested by the intestinal tract, which can cause gastrointestinal discomfort in some people.

Pros

  • It has zero calories and no carbs.

  • It does not raise blood sugar or insulin levels.

  • Its active compound passes into the urine without being used by the body.

  • In its granulated form it is easy to use to replace real sugar in recipes.

  • It may prevent dental plaque and cavities compared to other sweeteners.

Cons

  • It doesn’t have the same mouthfeel as sugar – it has a cooling sensation on the tongue.

  • It can cause bloating, gas and diarrhea in some people (though not as much as other sugar alcohols).

  • Absorbing erythritol and then excreting it via the kidneys could potentially have negative health consequences (none are known at this time).

Sweetness: About 70% as sweet as table sugar.

Products: Granulated erythritol or blends of erythritol and stevia.


Option #3: Monk fruit

While it’s derived from a round, green fruit that’s been grown for centuries in Southeast Asia, monk fruit is a relatively new sugar substitute on the market. Also called luo han guo, monk fruit was generally dried and used in herbal teas, soups and broths in Asian medicine. It was cultivated by monks in Northern Thailand and Southern China, hence its more popular name.

Although the fruit in whole form contains fructose and sucrose, monk fruit’s intense sweetness – 250 times as strong as sugar – is provided by non-caloric compounds called mogrosides, which can replace sugar. In 1995, Proctor & Gamble patented a method of solvent extraction of the mogrosides from monk fruit.

While the US FDA has not ruled on monk fruit as GRAS (generally regarded as safe) it has publicly noted that it accepts manufacturers’ GRAS determination. In the last few years more than 500 monk fruit products have come to market in the US. Monk fruit has not yet been accepted for sale by the European Union, but approval appears to be pending.

Pros

  • It does not raise blood sugar or insulin levels.

  • It has a better taste profile, with less bitterness of after taste, than stevia. In fact, it is often mixed with stevia to reduce cost and blunt stevia’s aftertaste.

  • It is also mixed with erythritol to reduce expense and improve use in cooking.

  • It doesn’t cause digestive upset.

Cons

  • It is expensive.

  • It is often mixed with other “fillers” like inulin, prebiotic fibres and other undeclared ingredients.

  • Be careful of labels that say “propriety blend” as it may have little active mogroside ingredients.

Sweetness: 250 times as sweet as sugar.

Products: Granulated blends with erythritol or stevia, pure liquid drops, or liquid drops with stevia; also used in replacement products like monkfruit-sweetened artificial maple syrup and chocolate syrup.


Low carb: xylitol

If you chew sugar-free gum, you are usually chewing xylitol. It is the most common-sugar-free sweetener in commercial gums and mouthwashes.

Like erythritol, xylitol is a sugar alcohol derived from plants. It is produced commercially from the fibrous, woody parts of corn cobs or birch trees through a multi-step chemical extraction process. The result is a granular crystal that tastes like sugar, but is not sugar.

Xylitol is low carb, but not zero carb. Xylitol’s carbs can quickly add up on a keto diet, so it’s not a great option.

Pros

  • Xylitol has a low glycemic index of 13, and only about 50% is absorbed in your small intestine.

  • When used in small amounts, it has a minor impact on blood sugar and insulin levels.

  • It has about half the calories, but the same taste as sugar.

  • It can replace sugar 1 for 1 in recipes.

  • It’s been shown to help prevent cavities when chewed in gum.

Cons

  • It can cause significant digestive upset (gas, bloating, diarrhea) even when consumed in small amounts.

  • It is highly toxic to dogs and other pets – even a small bite of a product made with xylitol can be fatal to dogs.

Sweetness: Equivalent in sweetness to table sugar.

Product: Organic granulated xylitol made from birch wood extraction.

Newer Sweeteners

The following sweeteners are quite new and aren’t widely available at this time. Moreover, very little is known about their long-term impacts on health because there isn’t much research on them.

Inulin-based sweeteners

Inulin is a member of the fructans family, which includes a fiber known as fructo-oligosaccharides (FOS). As a fiber, it provides no digestible carbs and isn’t absorbed from the digestive tract. Although it’s found in some vegetables like onions and Jerusalem artichokes, chicory is the main source of inulin used in low-carb sweeteners and products.

Because inulin is rapidly fermented by gut bacteria, it can cause gas, diarrhea, and other unpleasant digestive symptoms, especially at higher intakes.

Indeed, many people have reported these symptoms after consuming inulin-based sweeteners. However, inulin appears to be safe when consumed in small amounts.

Sweetness: 70-80% of the sweetness of sugar

Allulose

In 2015, allulose was approved as a low-calorie sweetener for sale to the public. It’s classified as a “rare sugar” because it occurs naturally in only a few foods, such as wheat, raisins, and figs. Although it has a molecular structure almost identical to fructose, the body isn’t able to metabolize allulose. Instead, nearly all of it passes into the urine without being absorbed, thereby contributing negligible carbs and calories.

Some studies in animals suggest there may be health benefits to consuming allulose, but human research has been mixed.

It reportedly tastes like sugar and doesn’t seem to cause digestive side effects when consumed in small amounts. However, large doses may cause diarrhea, abdominal pain, and nausea.´

Additionally, it is much more expensive than other sweeteners and isn’t widely available. Allulose has received GRAS (Generally Regarded as Safe) status from the FDA.

Sweetness: 100% of the sweetness of table sugar

Yakon syrup

Yakon syrup comes from the root of the yacón plant native to South America. It is a truly “natural” sweetener, similar to maple syrup. However, like inulin, yakon syrup contains fructo-oligosaccharides, which can cause digestive discomfort.

It has a lower glycemic index (GI) than most other sugars because a portion of the syrup is fiber. Still, one tablespoon of yakon syrup contains some digestible carbs (sugar). The exact amount can vary, but some estimates put it at around 9 to 13 grams of carbs per 100 grams of yacon root.

Because yakon syrup is much more concentrated, however, you’ll get this same amount of carbs in about 2 tablespoons of yakon syrup.

Sweetness: About 75% as sweet as sugar.

BochaSweet

BochaSweet is one of the newest sweeteners on the market. It’s made from an extract of the kabocha, a pumpkin-like squash from Japan. This extract reportedly has the same taste as white sugar, yet because of its chemical structure, it supposedly isn’t absorbed and contributes no calories or carbs.

Unfortunately, although it has received great reviews online, very little is known is about its health effects because there are few, if any, published studies on kabocha extract.

Sweetness: 100% of the sweetness of table sugar.

 

Beware: deceptive sweeteners

Zero-Sweeteners-1.jpg

Do you know that some products with labels that identify them as “zero-calorie” sweeteners are almost 100% carbs?

Beware of Stevia in the Raw, Equal, Sweet’n Low and Splenda packets. They are labeled “zero calories” but they are not.

The FDA allows products with less than 1 gram of carbs and less than 4 calories per serving to be labeled “zero calories”. So manufacturers cleverly package about 0.9 grams of pure carbs (glucose/dextrose) mixed with a small dose of a more powerful artificial sweetener.

The labels reel in the consumer and satisfy the authorities. But the packages in fact contain almost 4 calories each, and almost a gram of carbs. On a keto diet that can quickly add up. Don’t be conned; don’t consume.

Ditch them for their deceptive marketing alone. Some of the artificial sweeteners, such as aspartame and sucralose, also have lingering health concerns.

Almost as bad as sugar: maltitol

Maltitol is another sugar alcohol. It is made from the hydrogenation of the corn-syrup by-product maltose. It behaves in cooking and production very much like pure sugar so it is very popular in commercial “sugar free” products, such as candy, desserts, and low-carb products. It is also less expensive for food producers to use than erythritol, xylitol, and other sugar alcohols.

Do not consume maltitol on a keto diet. It has been shown to raise blood sugar and increase insulin response.

It is not good for anyone with diabetes or pre-diabetes. It also has three-quarters of the calories as sugar.33

It is also a powerful laxative. While 50% of it is absorbed in the small intestine, the remaining 50% ferments in the colon. Studies have shown that maltitol may cause significant gastrointestinal symptoms (gas, bloating, diarrhea etc.) even when consumed in moderate amounts.

Sweetness: About 80% of the sweetness of table sugar.

Diet soft drinks on keto?

Can you drink diet soft drinks on a keto diet? We recommend you avoid them. Drink water, sparkling water, tea, or coffee instead.

As noted at the start of this guide, regular consumption of sweet substances, even with no calories, will maintain cravings for sweet tastes. Your palate will remain tied to sweet flavours and be less likely to learn to enjoy the natural, flavourful but less intense sweetness of keto foods.

Consuming diet beverages may make it also harder to lose weight.

This could be due to hormonal effects, other effects on satiety signals, or effects on gut microbiota.36

Other health concerns are suspected, but unproven, with many of the artificial sweeteners used, like aspartame, acesulfame K and sucralose.

If you must drink diet sodas, however, you will likely still stay in ketosis. Regular soda, sweetened with sugar or high fructose corn syrup, will kick you right out of ketosis. Do not consume.

A final word on keto sweeteners

Yes, it’s pretty clear, we’re not a fan of sweeteners. While some sweeteners may be better than others, the best strategy for achieving optimal health and weight loss may be learning to enjoy real foods in their unsweetened state.

A 2016 study found many of the positive research on sugar substitutes are funded by industry and full of conflict of interest, research bias and unreproduced findings.

It might take a little time for your taste buds to adapt, but over time, you may discover a whole new appreciation for the subtle sweetness of natural, unprocessed foods.

Sugar addiction

Can’t imagine living without sweet foods? If you try, do you find it almost impossible to curb the cravings? Do you find yourself then binging on sweets? You might be interested in our course on sugar addiction and how to take back control. And yes, you can do it!

Elizabeth Zuckerman